Giving the Bible what belongs to the Holy Spirit

There are certain things we hear so often in religious circles that we eventually stop questioning them. They become part of our vocabulary, part of how we understand God, and even part of how we determine whether something is true.
I've heard people say that the Bible is our final authority, that everything we believe must be filtered through Scripture, and that every answer we'll ever need can be found somewhere in its pages. I've also heard people insist that if something cannot be found in the Bible, it cannot possibly be from God.
For many years, I accepted these statements without giving them much thought. They sounded like expressions of respect for Scripture. But as I began examining the things I'd been taught, a question emerged that changed the way I approached these writings. Are these things the Bible actually says about itself, or are they things we've come to believe about the Bible?
I believe the Bible is a wonderful gift, and I value these writings tremendously. They've helped me understand the story of humanity, the covenants, the promises, and the extraordinary revelation of God that comes into full view in Jesus. I continue to discover things within them that deepen my understanding.
But we can deeply value something while misunderstanding its purpose. And when that happens, we can unintentionally give it a place it was never intended to occupy.
I wonder whether we've become so accustomed to approaching God through the Bible that we've started treating the Bible as though it were the relationship itself. We've developed an entire religious culture around studying, defending, interpreting, and debating Scripture. Yet those very writings speak of God dwelling within humanity, the Spirit teaching and guiding, Christ being our wisdom, and a New Covenant in which knowing God is no longer reserved for a select few.
If that's what Scripture reveals, shouldn't we take it seriously? And what might we discover if we allowed the Bible to occupy the place its own writers describe?

What Did Jesus Say About the Scriptures?
One of the most revealing conversations about Scripture comes from Jesus Himself. In John 5:39–40, He's speaking to religious leaders who were deeply devoted to the sacred writings. These weren't people who neglected Scripture. They studied it diligently, knew its teachings, and believed it held the answers concerning God and life.
Yet Jesus tells them that they search the Scriptures because they think life is found in them, while those same Scriptures testify about Him. He then points out that they are unwilling to come to Him to have life.
I've returned to this passage many times because I think it exposes something we can easily overlook. These people weren't lacking biblical knowledge. Their problem was that their familiarity with the writings had not led them to recognize the One those writings were revealing.
And here's what makes that so interesting. Jesus wasn't confronting people who considered Scripture unimportant. He was confronting people who considered it tremendously important, and still they missed what was standing right in front of them.
Could we be capable of doing the same thing today? Could someone spend an entire lifetime studying Scripture and still misunderstand the God those Scriptures reveal? Could someone become so committed to defending an interpretation that they resist the very truth the writings were intended to help them recognize?
Notice that Jesus doesn't tell them to abandon the Scriptures. He points them toward their purpose, which is to testify about Him. The writings are valuable because of what they communicate, but they aren't the Life they're communicating about.
We see something similar in Luke 24. After His resurrection, Jesus explains to two disciples what the Scriptures said concerning Himself. Later, He opens the minds of His disciples so they can understand the writings (Luke 24:27, 44–45).
These disciples already had access to the Scriptures. What changed wasn't the writing itself, but their understanding of what they were reading. Possessing Scripture, reading Scripture, and understanding what Scripture reveals are not necessarily the same thing.
What Does the Bible Actually Claim About Itself?
One of the passages most frequently quoted when discussing biblical authority is 2 Timothy 3:16–17. Paul describes Scripture as God-breathed and useful for teaching, correction, and training in righteousness, so that the person of God may be equipped for every good work.
That's a remarkable description, and I don't believe we need to minimize any part of it. But let's look more closely at what Paul actually says.
In verse 15, he reminds Timothy that he's known the sacred writings since childhood and that these writings are able to make him wise concerning salvation through faith in Christ Jesus. Paul was speaking about the sacred writings already available to Timothy, not a completed collection of New Testament books like the one we possess today.
And what does Paul say those writings accomplish? They make someone wise concerning salvation through Christ. They're useful for teaching, correction, and training, and they help equip people for good works.
That's an incredibly valuable purpose, but Paul doesn't say that Scripture replaces the inward teaching of the Spirit. He doesn't say God's communication is limited to a collection of writings, and he doesn't identify Scripture as the source of the Life it reveals. Those are conclusions that go beyond what he explicitly says.
Some might respond that if Scripture is God-breathed, it must carry authority. I understand that reasoning, and Paul is clearly making a significant statement about the value and origin of Scripture. But recognizing its importance doesn't require us to give it every responsibility belonging to Christ and the Spirit.
Consider 2 Peter 1:20–21, where Peter discusses the prophetic Scriptures. He explains that prophecy didn't originate merely from human initiative. The prophets spoke from God as they were carried along by the Holy Spirit.
Even when the biblical writers discuss the origin of Scripture, they direct our attention to the activity of the Spirit. So why would we assume that the Spirit's role in communicating and revealing truth has now been replaced by what was written?
When Did "The Word of God" Become Another Name for the Bible?
There's another assumption that has shaped how many of us read Scripture. Whenever we hear the expression "the word of God," we automatically think of the Bible.
We've heard the Bible called God's Word for so long that the expressions have become interchangeable in our minds. But when we examine the language of the New Testament, we discover that its writers used several Greek words when speaking about God's communication, messages, and sacred writings.
One of those words is logos. Depending on the context, it can refer to a word, message, statement, reason, or communication. In John 1:1–14, John uses logos when introducing the Word who was with God, was God, and became flesh. He's speaking about Jesus.
In Acts 12:24, Luke tells us that the word of God continued to spread and multiply. Was Luke describing the distribution of written Bibles? Of course not. He was describing the spread of God's message as it was proclaimed and received.
Another Greek word is rhēma, which commonly refers to a spoken word, saying, or utterance. In Luke 3:2, the word of God comes to John in the wilderness. The passage describes God communicating with John, not John discovering a passage in a collection of writings.
In Romans 10:17, Paul connects faith with hearing the message concerning Christ. His discussion concerns the proclamation of good news and the response of those who hear it.
Then there's graphē, the Greek word used specifically for Scripture or sacred writing. When Paul speaks about Scripture being God-breathed in 2 Timothy 3:16, he uses graphē. When Jesus refers to Scripture in John 10:35, that same word appears.
Now, these words aren't completely separate categories. Logos and rhēma can refer to words preserved in writing, and written Scripture can certainly communicate God's message. In John 10:35, Jesus even connects God's word with a passage of Scripture.
So the point isn't that God's word can never refer to something written. The point is that the biblical writers didn't automatically mean "the Bible" whenever they spoke about God's word.
Sometimes they were describing God's communication to someone. Sometimes they were describing a message being proclaimed, and sometimes, as in John's Gospel, they were speaking about Jesus Himself. The context determines what is being described.
We've become so accustomed to calling the Bible the Word of God that we've stopped asking what the biblical writers themselves meant when they used that expression. The Scriptures preserve invaluable testimony about God speaking, revealing, and making Himself known, but God's ability to communicate was never confined to ink and pages.
Who Did Jesus Say Would Teach and Guide Us?
Jesus spoke extensively about what the Holy Spirit would do, yet many of the responsibilities He attributed to the Spirit have gradually been assigned to the Bible in our religious culture.
In John 14:26, Jesus tells His disciples that the Holy Spirit will teach them and bring to their remembrance what He has said. In John 16:13, He speaks about the Spirit of truth guiding them into all truth.
These statements were first spoken to the disciples who were with Jesus during that remarkable period of covenant transition. Their original setting matters, especially when Jesus speaks about remembering His words and understanding what was about to unfold. But they also reveal something important about how God makes Himself known.
Jesus describes the Spirit as actively teaching, communicating, and guiding. And these aren't isolated statements.
In 1 Corinthians 2, Paul speaks about the Spirit revealing the things of God and helping people understand what has been freely given to them. He concludes by saying that we have the mind of Christ.
In Romans 8:14, Paul describes people being led by the Spirit of God. In 1 Corinthians 1:30, he identifies Christ as our wisdom.
And in 1 John 2:27, John reminds his readers of the anointing that abides within them and teaches them. Within that same conversation, he encourages them to remain in what they received concerning the Son. John isn't encouraging ignorance or rejecting what they've heard. He's recognizing the inward activity of the Spirit as central to their understanding.
Now, consider how we've often approached these things. We've developed a culture where people can become uncomfortable with the idea of someone being taught or led by the Spirit unless they can immediately produce a Bible verse to support what they're hearing.
We tell people the Spirit lives within them, that they have the mind of Christ, and that Christ is their wisdom. But then we sometimes teach them to distrust anything they recognize within themselves until an external source confirms it.
I find that contradiction worth examining because it raises a question about what we actually believe concerning the Spirit's presence. Do we believe the Spirit teaches and guides, or have we reduced those promises to something that happens only when we're reading Scripture?
The Spirit can certainly speak through Scripture. I've experienced passages becoming clear in ways they hadn't been before, sometimes challenging assumptions I'd carried for years. But the Spirit's ability to use Scripture doesn't mean Scripture becomes the Spirit.
When Jesus speaks about the Spirit teaching and guiding, He's describing something more personal than a life governed exclusively by written information. He's describing a living relationship, and I wonder whether we've become more comfortable with information about God than with the reality of knowing Him.
The New Covenant Was Never About Replacing One Written Code With Another
This conversation becomes even more significant when we consider the transition from the Old Covenant to the New.
In Jeremiah 31:31–34, God promises a New Covenant in which His instruction will be placed within His people and written upon their hearts. He goes on to describe a people who know Him, from the least to the greatest.
The promise concerns something taking place within people. Knowing God would no longer depend upon the old covenant arrangement.
Hebrews 8 revisits this prophecy and connects it with the New Covenant established through Jesus. We find similar language in Ezekiel 36:26–27, where God speaks about giving His people a new heart and placing His Spirit within them.
Then there's Paul's remarkable discussion in 2 Corinthians 3. He tells the Corinthians that they are letters of Christ, written not with ink but with the Spirit of the living God, and not on tablets of stone but on human hearts.
Paul contrasts the ministry associated with letters engraved on stone with the ministry of the Spirit. He's discussing the covenant associated with Moses and the transition taking place through Jesus. He's not rejecting all writing or instruction. After all, he's communicating these thoughts through a letter.
But the distinction he's making is significant. The New Covenant wasn't simply about replacing one collection of written instructions with another. It involved an entirely different way of understanding and experiencing the relationship between God and humanity.
The writings testify to a reality in which God dwells within His people, the Spirit is active within them, and knowing God is no longer dependent upon the former covenant arrangement.
Yet when we miss this transition, we can take writings that testify about freedom in the Spirit and turn them into another external system through which people are taught to measure their relationship with God.
Instead of helping people recognize the Life within them, we can unintentionally train them to remain dependent upon someone else's understanding of what that Life is supposed to look like.
I wonder how many people have spent years surrounded by biblical teaching while still feeling incapable of recognizing God's leading for themselves. They've been taught to trust the system interpreting the writings more than the relationship those writings describe.
Everything Must Be Filtered Through the Bible. But Whose Understanding?
There's a statement I've heard countless times: "Everything must be filtered through the Bible." At first, that sounds like a responsible approach to understanding truth, but there's something we don't talk about nearly enough.
Nobody reads the Bible without interpreting it.
Every one of us approaches Scripture with assumptions about God, humanity, history, and life. We bring what we've been taught, what we've experienced, and what we've come to believe. Whether we realize it or not, those things influence how we understand what we're reading.
Think about how many people have read the same Bible and arrived at completely different conclusions.
Some believe God will eternally torment much of humanity, while others read the same writings and see the reconciliation of all. Some believe the kingdom is still waiting to arrive in its fullness, while others recognize the kingdom and the promises concerning its coming within the first-century covenant transition. Some believe humanity remains separated from God until certain conditions are met, while others understand Jesus to have already accomplished reconciliation.
The people holding these different views can all quote Scripture. So when someone tells me that everything must be filtered through the Bible, I find myself wanting to ask, "Whose interpretation of the Bible are we using?"
Because very often, what someone actually means is that everything must agree with the understanding of Scripture they've already accepted. And those are two very different claims.
I've experienced this in my own life. There were things I believed and defended for years because I was convinced the Bible taught them. I knew the passages, understood the arguments, and had answers ready whenever someone questioned my position.
But as I began examining those passages within their historical setting, their covenant context, and the circumstances of the people they were written to, I discovered that some of my strongest convictions weren't nearly as solid as I thought.
Sometimes I wasn't defending what Scripture actually meant. I was defending what someone had taught me Scripture meant, and that's a humbling realization.
Consider the Bereans in Acts 17:11. They're often mentioned as an example of examining everything through Scripture. Luke describes them as receiving Paul's message eagerly and examining the Scriptures to see whether what he was saying was true.
That's a wonderful example of taking the writings seriously, but notice something else. They were examining Scripture in response to a message that challenged their existing understanding. They didn't simply reject Paul's message because it differed from their expectations. They were willing to look again.
Their example encourages careful examination and a willingness to reconsider what we think we know. That's quite different from using our present interpretation as an unquestionable standard against which every new insight must be judged.
There's nothing wrong with examining what we believe through Scripture. The problem arises when our understanding of Scripture becomes something we're no longer willing to examine. At that point, we may be protecting our interpretations more than honoring the writings themselves.
What Happens When Our Picture of God Doesn't Look Like Jesus?
If Jesus is the full revelation of the Father, what should we do when our interpretation of Scripture gives us a picture of God that appears to contradict what Jesus reveals?
In John 14:9, Jesus tells Philip that anyone who has seen Him has seen the Father. Hebrews 1:1–3 explains that God spoke through the prophets in various ways in the past, but had now spoken through His Son, who is described as the exact representation of God's being.
That's an extraordinary claim because Jesus isn't simply another voice contributing information about what God is like. He reveals the Father in a way that brings the earlier testimony into clearer focus.
And yet, I've encountered people who describe God in ways that bear little resemblance to Jesus, then defend those descriptions by pointing to passages they believe support them.
They'll describe a Father who remains angry with humanity, unwilling to forgive without certain conditions being satisfied, or determined to abandon much of His creation to everlasting suffering.
Then they'll point to a passage and say, "Well, that's what the Bible says." But what if we've misunderstood what we're reading?
What if we're taking words spoken within a particular covenant setting and treating them as timeless descriptions of God's character? What if we're overlooking the historical circumstances, the original audience, or the purpose of the language being used?
And what if our inherited picture of God has been influencing how we interpret Scripture more than the revelation of Jesus has?
Remember what happened in Luke 24. Jesus helped His disciples understand their own Scriptures in light of what had taken place through Him. He didn't discard the writings. He opened their understanding.
I think we should approach Scripture with that same willingness to see something we haven't recognized before. When I encounter a passage that appears inconsistent with the Father revealed in Jesus, I don't feel obligated to defend the interpretation I've inherited.
I want to examine it more carefully. Who is speaking? Who is being addressed? What's happening in their world? What covenant is involved? And how does this passage fit within the revelation that comes into full view in Jesus?
Those questions have helped me recognize that sometimes the thing I'm defending isn't Scripture itself, but my understanding of it. For me, Jesus is the clearest revelation of who the Father is, and that conviction shapes how I approach everything else.
But What About the Danger of Being Misled?
I can imagine someone reading this and asking, "If we're supposed to be led by the Spirit, how do we know we're not simply following our own thoughts or feelings?"
That's a fair question, but the same concern applies to our interpretations of Scripture. People have used the Bible to justify things we now recognize as harmful. Religious leaders have defended control, exclusion, prejudice, and the mistreatment of others while claiming biblical support.
Having a Bible verse attached to an idea doesn't automatically make our understanding of that verse correct. And claiming to be led by the Spirit doesn't automatically mean every impression or belief is accurate either.
That's why discernment matters.
John encouraged his readers to test the spirits in 1 John 4:1. Paul encouraged the Thessalonians to test what they were hearing and hold on to what was good in 1 Thessalonians 5:19–21.
Neither writer was suggesting that people should abandon the Spirit's activity. They were encouraging people to recognize what was genuinely true and good.
And I believe the revelation of God in Jesus gives us a beautiful foundation for that discernment. Does what we're embracing reflect the Father revealed in Jesus? Does it deepen our understanding of reconciliation and union? Does it produce love, wisdom, peace, and genuine freedom?
Paul describes the fruit of the Spirit in Galatians 5:22–23, including love, joy, peace, patience, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness, and self-control. Those qualities tell us something about the kind of life the Spirit expresses.
Of course, we still need humility. We need to listen, learn, question, and remain willing to recognize when we've misunderstood something.
But I don't believe the answer to the possibility of misunderstanding is to distrust the Spirit within us and become dependent upon someone else's interpretation of Scripture. We can value the writings, learn from one another, examine what we're hearing, and remain attentive to the Life within us.
When Knowing Scripture Becomes a Substitute for Knowing God
Something else concerns me about the place we've given the Bible in religious culture. We've often made knowledge of Scripture one of the primary ways we measure someone's spiritual maturity.
We admire people who can quote passages from memory, explain difficult doctrines, and defend theological positions. Sometimes we assume that the person with the greatest command of biblical information must also possess the deepest understanding of God.
But is that necessarily true? Jesus encountered people with tremendous scriptural knowledge who struggled to recognize the Father He was revealing.
Paul himself had been deeply trained in the writings and traditions of his people. In Philippians 3, he describes his religious credentials and the confidence he once placed in them. Yet his encounter with Christ profoundly changed how he understood what mattered.
Knowledge alone doesn't guarantee understanding, and understanding a doctrine doesn't mean we're expressing the Life that doctrine describes.
Paul makes an interesting observation in 1 Corinthians 8:1 when he writes that knowledge can puff people up while love builds them up. He wasn't encouraging ignorance. He was recognizing that knowledge can shape us in very different ways depending on how we use it.
And I think we've seen the consequences of that throughout religious culture. We've watched people debate Scripture against Scripture, each convinced they're defending God. We've seen friendships damaged, communities divided, and people condemned because their understanding of a passage differed from someone else's.
Entire systems have developed around deciding who has the correct interpretation, who belongs, and who should be excluded. Meanwhile, the very things Jesus revealed about love, reconciliation, and life can become secondary.
If our understanding of Scripture continually produces suspicion, hostility, control, and condemnation, shouldn't we examine what we're doing with that understanding? What kind of fruit is it producing?
I believe people often begin to resemble the God they've come to believe in. If someone understands God primarily through fear, punishment, and separation, those ideas can shape how they relate to themselves and others. But recognizing the Father revealed in Jesus, whose heart is for reconciliation and life, can reshape how we engage with humanity.
This is why Scripture's proper place matters. It affects more than how we read a book. It influences how we understand God, how we see ourselves, and how we treat one another.
What Does Reading the Bible Look Like When It's in Its Proper Place?
I don't want anyone to finish this conversation thinking I'm suggesting we should stop reading Scripture or become careless about what it says. I believe restoring the Bible to its proper place can make our engagement with it far more meaningful.
Instead of approaching every passage as though it must contain a direct instruction for our personal lives, we can begin by asking what the writer was communicating to the people originally being addressed.
We can explore their world, the covenant they were under, the circumstances they were facing, and the questions they were trying to answer.
We can recognize that a statement spoken to Israel under the Law of Moses wasn't automatically spoken to humanity living in the reality of the New Covenant. We can understand why certain warnings and promises mattered within the first-century covenant transition rather than assuming they're describing events still awaiting fulfillment in our own future.
Sometimes we're reading a historical account. Sometimes we're encountering prophetic language, poetry, wisdom, a personal letter, or a conversation taking place within a world very different from our own.
Recognizing those distinctions helps us appreciate what the writings were actually communicating. And throughout that exploration, we can remain attentive to the Spirit, allowing what we're reading to challenge our assumptions and open our understanding.
We can also learn through relationships, experiences, conversations, observations, and the countless ways life invites us to grow in understanding. The Spirit isn't limited to our reading schedule, and knowing God isn't something that begins when we open a Bible and ends when we close it.
Remember Paul's description in 2 Corinthians 3:3. He tells the Corinthians that they are living letters of Christ, written by the Spirit on human hearts. I love that picture because it takes the conversation beyond words preserved on a page into Life being expressed through people.
We aren't simply people who've been given information about God. We're people in whom the Life revealed in Jesus is being expressed. The Bible helps us understand that reality, but the reality itself is something we live and participate in.
Returning the Bible to Its Proper Place
As I've continued this journey, I've become increasingly grateful for the Scriptures. But my appreciation for them looks different than it once did.
I no longer feel the need to defend every interpretation I've inherited. I'm comfortable examining familiar passages again, asking difficult questions, and recognizing that some things I've believed may need to change. I don't see that as rejecting Scripture. I see it as taking these writings seriously enough to allow them to challenge the assumptions I've brought to them.
And I no longer believe my relationship with God depends upon how much biblical information I possess. Christ is my Life. The Spirit dwells within me, and the wisdom and relationship revealed through Jesus are realities I'm learning to recognize and express in everyday life.
The Bible helps me understand that reality, but it didn't create it.
I think we've spent so much time teaching people how to study the Bible that we haven't always helped them recognize what it means to know God. And I wonder what might change if we began giving that relationship the attention Scripture itself gives it.
What if people became more confident in recognizing the Life within them? What if they began understanding Scripture through the revelation of Jesus rather than through fear of arriving at an unacceptable interpretation? What if our conversations about the Bible became opportunities for discovery rather than competitions to determine who has the correct answers?
I believe Scripture has an incredibly valuable place in that kind of environment. We can read it, discuss it, question our interpretations, and discover things together without turning every disagreement into a threat.
I keep coming back to that conversation Jesus had with the religious leaders in John 5. They had the Scriptures, knew the writings, and believed they understood the things of God. Yet the One those Scriptures testified about was standing in front of them, and they couldn't recognize Him.
That conversation continues to challenge me because I don't want my familiarity with Scripture to become a substitute for recognizing the Life it reveals. I want to keep learning from these writings while remaining open to having my understanding challenged and enlarged.
Perhaps the question we need to consider isn't simply whether we've given the Bible enough authority. Perhaps we need to ask whether we've given the Bible responsibilities that belong to the One it was always intended to reveal.
The Scriptures can testify about Life, help us understand what God has accomplished through Jesus, and provide extraordinary insight into the relationship we now enjoy. But the Life itself has never been confined to a book, and knowing that Life is the very reality those writings invite us to recognize.

Get The New Book!
I AM - The Life You've Always Been Looking For: Identity, Union, and the Realization That You Have Everything
Available On Amazon:
Continue The Journey
If this essay resonated with you, don't let the conversation end here. Urban Eden is more than a collection of articles—it's an ongoing journey of exploring identity, seeing God more clearly, and engaging life more fully.
Explore more reflections that challenge assumptions and invite deeper thinking.
Continue the conversation through honest discussions and fresh perspectives.
Go beyond the essays with books that unpack these ideas in greater depth.
Join us Friday evenings or discover more about our community.
Meet Serge
Serge is an author, minister, podcast host, and the founder of Urban Eden Community. his passion is helping people see God more clearly, awaken to who they are, and engage life more fully. Through essays, conversations, books, and community, his hope is to create spaces where people can ask honest questions and discover the life that's already present within them.
Stay Connected
Join others who are exploring these conversations each week.




Comments